Cookie & Whoopie Pies

Cookie & Whoopie Pies

  • Custom handmade buttercream frosted sugar cookies for a baby shower

    Custom Consultation

    Let us bake a special bite of happiness! Looking for something special? Whatever you need, we'll make it from scratch for you. Add this to your cart if you're looking for something beyond what's on our menu. Staci will give you a call to discuss your...

    $0.00
    Choose Options
  • Handmade oatmeal buttercream cookie pie

    Oatmeal Buttercream Cookie Pie

    Handmade from scratch just for you. Move over, Little Debbie! A rich buttercream filling bookended by two hearty oatmeal cookies has made this one of our most requested items. We're so grateful you'd take the time to visit our site. If you have a...

    $1.75
    Choose Options
  • Handmade peanut butter chocolate cookie pie

    Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookie Pie

    Handmade from scratch just for you. As my fiance says, "I'd betray my country for this (we're deep into 'The Americans')." A combination of our two favorite things: chocolate frosting and peanut butter cookies. Let us know if you'd like to swap the...

    $1.75
    Choose Options
  • Handmade red velvet buttercream whoopie pie

    Red Velvet Buttercream Whoopie Pie

    Handmade from scratch just for you. Move over, Little Debbie! A rich buttercream filling with a touch of chocolate ganache is bookended by two hearty red velvet cookies to make for a delicious treat. We're so grateful you'd take the time to visit our...

    $1.75
    Choose Options
  • Handmade chocolate peanut butter whoopie pie

    Chocolate Peanut Butter Whoopie Pie

    Handmade from scratch just for you. An ode to our beloved Buckeye state - this whoopie pie is subtle chocolate meets rich peanut butter icing. We're so grateful you'd take the time to visit our site. If you have a special request, please email Staci...

    $2.50
    Choose Options
Compare Selected